Murder Mystery Party Drinks: 5 Prohibition-Era Cocktails (1920s Theme)

For a 1920s murder mystery party, the atmosphere is everything—and drinks play a central role in setting the tone.

These classic Prohibition-era cocktails are perfect for recreating the elegance and intrigue of a speakeasy setting, making them an ideal addition to scenarios like The Curse of the Quora Diamond.

Why these cocktails work for a murder mystery party”

• Instantly reinforce the 1920s setting

• Easy to serve in a cocktail-style event (your recommended format)

• Add to the immersive experience without requiring complex setup

• Can be adapted into a simple bar menu

How to serve these during your event”

• Offer 2–3 signature cocktails

• Pre-batch where possible to avoid long waiting times

• Use simple labels or a printed menu to match the theme

• Consider one non-alcoholic option for inclusivity